Denying Manning Exercise: A Ploy To Muddle His Mind

Denying Manning Exercise is Ploy To Muddle His Mind

By Sherwood Ross

Taking away one’s freedom to exercise is one of the subtlest and most debilitating tortures that can be inflicted on a human being. Yet that is how the Pentagon’s Robert Gates, with the backing of President Obama, is punishing PFC Bradley Manning. The Army intelligence specialist’s alleged offense is to have turned over confidential files to WikiLeaks in part to expose the arbitrary killing of Iraqi civilians and Reuters journalists in Baghdad on July 12, 2007. They were mowed down from an Army Apache helicopter gunship. Rather than welcoming the infamous “Collateral Damage” video proof Manning furnished of this massacre and punishing the actors, Gates, a former CIA director with apparently no scruples, is punishing Manning.

President Obama has said he has been assured by the Pentagon that Manning is being treated “appropriately” in a way that is “meeting our basic standards.”

But David House, an MIT researcher and friend, says Manning told him on a visit last December 18th that “he does not receive any substantive exercise and cannot perform even basic exercises in his cell. When told of the Pentagon’s statement that he did indeed receive exercise, Manning’s reply was that he is able to exercise insofar as walking in chains is a form of exercise.” (“Chains you can believe in?”)

In a nation that worships sports and where tens of millions fill gyms and jog along the roadsides, it is ironic that this 23-year-old Crescent, Okla., native is denied by Gates the right even to do a push-up or a sit-up in his cell and is required to drag chains in the one hour per day he is allowed to walk at the Marine Corp brig in Quantico, Va. And should Manning pause for any reason during that hour to rest, he is returned to his cell. Of course, the Army calls this sham “exercise” but who has ever heard of any American military unit required to “exercise” in this manner?

The object of denying Bradley exercise is to weaken both his body and his mind so that if the Army ever decides to bring his case to trial, it will be trying a human vegetable, perhaps a distraught man even incapable of understanding the charges against him, incapable of assisting his lawyers in his defense. Meanwhile, the Pentagon is torturing this innocent man by constant (every five minutes’) interrogation, sleep deprivation, and humiliation—this last by forcing him to stand at roll call stark naked.

Exercise denial might well be classified among the “clean tortures” that leave no marks and that have been devised in recent years by the western democracies, notably the U.S., Britain, and France, where official conduct is subject to media surveillance. “Torturers, on their own or at the direction of others and for whatever reason, seem to have turned more and more toward techniques that leave few marks,” writes Darius Rejali in his definitive “Torture and Democracy”(Princeton University Press).

Regular, healthful exercise strengthens the mind—and the Pentagon is not going to allow that. The prescient Mahatma Gandhi knew this years ago and preached exercise to strengthen practitioners of non-violent resistance, or satyagraha. He wrote in his book, “Non-Violent Resistance”(Dover Publications), “The object of the various exercises was to strengthen and purify the body in order to secure control of the mind.” Gandhi added, “If the Satyagrahi is not healthy in mind and body, he may perhaps fail in mustering complete fearlessness.”

Since Gandhi’s day there have been a ton of studies linking exercise to mental well-being. “Exercise has been shown to have tremendous benefits for mental health,” Science Daily quotes Jasper Smits as saying. Smits is director of the Anxiety Research and Treatment Program at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. After reviewing “dozens” of population-based and clinical studies he found, “Individuals who exercise report fewer symptoms of anxiety and depression, and lower levels of stress and anger.” Smits calls for 150 minutes a week of moderate-intensity activity or 75 minutes a week of vigorous-intensity activity, according to Science Daily.

Leonard Holmes, a clinical psychologist who has worked at the VA Medical Center in Hampton, Va., and taught health psychology at the College of William and Mary, wrote on “We know that exercise has positive effects on the brain. Researchers at Duke University demonstrated several years ago that exercise has antidepressant properties…. The bottom line is that most of us feel good after exercise.” An individual is said by experts to need exercise that will improve cardiovascular health, build strength, and and enhance flexibility. This might include cycling or running three days a week and weight-lifting three days a week.

Denying Manning exercise contributes to making it tough for him to sleep. As Judith Easton, personal training director at Galter Life Center, Chicago, told Home Fit Pro, “Exercise leads to an increase of energy and better sleeping patterns, which may also explain why it is so helpful to people with depression. Low energy and poor sleep are common symptoms of depression.”

While Manning shuffles about in chains for attempting to stop the killing in Iraq, the Imperial President Obama—who has just plunged the U.S. into war in Libya without bothering to obtain the consent of Congress—apparently isn’t scrimping on his workouts. Obama once told Men’s Health magazine, “Usually I get in about 45 minutes, six days a week. I’ll lift one day, do cardio the next.” And his passion for basketball is well known. As for wife Michelle, the First Lady reportedly is a fan of cross-training, mixing exercises that include weight-lifting, the treadmill, stair-stepper and spin bike. AP says Obama and his wife “have exercise routines that would put most people to shame.”

May the president and First Lady exercise well and sleep well. Bradley Manning, whose treatment violates the anti-torture statutes, isn’t. So much for “doing unto others” and the Golden Rule. And as for shame…

About the Writer: Sherwood Ross is a Miami-based public relations consultant who also writes on political topics. To contribute to his Anti-War News Service or comment, reach him at [email protected]

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VT, VT authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors, partners, technicians, or the Veterans Today Network and its assigns. LEGAL NOTICE - COMMENT POLICY

Posted by on March 30, 2011, With Reads Filed under Military. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

9 Responses to "Denying Manning Exercise: A Ploy To Muddle His Mind"

  1. Paul  April 5, 2011 at 9:13 pm

    The biggest queston has to be ….what is wrong with the American people who would let this happen to this youg son of America shame shame …..
    The U.S Military is the property of the people….what is wrong Americans …

  2. PR Smith  March 31, 2011 at 10:12 am

    wee, now, even if Manning is acquitted, they can still hold him for the rest of his life. Only in America, free-est country in the world.

  3. Sherwood Ross  March 31, 2011 at 7:39 am

    Dear Matt, you are quite right that Manning has not been convicted of any crime—yet he is being punished in a way to destroy his mind and body that will leave no marks. Since the Pentagon has betrayed its prejudice against Manning by these actions, how can it be entrusted with a fair judicial procedure if they ever decide to prosecute him? The Pentagon can’t. As for an organization that allows its troops to shoot civilians and reporters, it has obviously become a totalitarian entity. Recall that when Secretary Gates was a CIA employee, he urged the bombing of Nicaragua, a country that never attacked the U.S. Hope you will write your Congress person and check out the Manning support sites on the Internet. All best, Sherwood

  4. Rev.. A. M. Clark  March 31, 2011 at 7:15 am

    I, have a story to send, that will boggle a disabled veterans mind.
    Please give me an e-mail or FX number.

  5. Matt Ford, M.P.A.  March 31, 2011 at 6:45 am

    PFC Manning has not been convicted of any crime. What has happened to our system of law, where you are innocent until proven guilty?

  6. Sherwood Ross  March 30, 2011 at 9:25 pm

    Dear Wallytron, nobody deserves to be treated as Manning is being treated—not even his tormentors. Why not put your anger at them aside and write a letter to your congressperson urging humanitarian treatment for Manning? Thanks for writing, all best, Sherwood

  7. wallytron  March 30, 2011 at 6:48 pm

    If I was president I would make a surprise visit and make the base commander serve time the same way

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

From Veterans Today Network