When is enough “enough?”


by Ed Mattson


I’m sick and tired of watching and listening to pundits who profess concern over the minimum wage. They all read from the same talking points…”The minimum wage at $7.25/hour is not enough to support a family…and on and on”. Well, what is enough? How about $20/hour? $25/hr? Or why even stop there…why not $50/hr?

In the first place, the minimum wage is so bogus it defies reasonable thought. It is a “vote-getter” for the liberals to bring up before every election, just to show how mean and cruel conservatives really are.

Today it is in the forefront battle of  Black Friday facing American retailers who are trying to make it amid the biggest push ever by government regulations (taxes, healthcare, permits, licensing, and other punishment) to kill free enterprise. Yes, the class envy war is being waged against the heart of American entrepreneurial spirit. As in the past, businesses tread water all year with the hopes for a profitable year resting on the Holiday purchasing season.  A very large percentage of the retailers rely on minimum wage personnel so they can be competitive. So according to the logic used by liberals, let’s raise the minimum wage killing off even more business and putting more people on the unemployment rolls.

Now before everyone has a hissy-fit about how cruel and inhumane my line of thinking is, lets analyze the minimum wage in a serious manner and not on touchy-feely, warm and fuzzy, “make me feel good because I am so concerned” reasoning.

The minimum wage is $7.25/hour. At this rate it enables first-time job seekers and other entry-level personnel an opportunity to gain employment and allows small businesses to compete in the marketplace. Remember, small business (there are about 6.79 million small businesses) accounts for 80% of the total employment. But many of these small businesses are not exactly thriving. Nearly four in five businesses have no employees at all, and they make an average $45,000 per year, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Meanwhile, the share of new startups that employ workers continues to fall, according to the Kauffman Index of Entrepreneurial Activity.

Small business account for about 65% of all employment in the US over the last 17 years, and 52% are employed by businesses that have 20 or less employees. Every time the minimum wage rate is raised, business is discouraged from hiring people. As it is 5.2% of the workforce is paid at minimum wage.

According to the Nevada Sun newspaper…In her column last week on the minimum wage, “Working poor shouldn’t be forced to live on “$15,000 per year,” said Rep. Lynn Woolsey, D-Calif., but that fails to include the earned income credit, the additional child credit and public assistance when she talks about getting by on a minimum wage, all of which can double someone’s income. This bit of public support is far superior to those of us working and paying taxes than just handing out welfare checks while folks kick back on their porches.

The minimum wage is meant as “entry level” minimum pay. It was never intended to be the pinnacle job achievement, which the liberals seem intent on establishing. Very few workers who start at minimum wage remain on it. Most move into better paying positions either at the current company or at a newer company. The minimum wage level prepares many who do not have an education to learn a specific skill.  Yes, even in menial jobs, those learned skills might be limited to learning how to show up to work on time, order taking, or other skills and disciplines required for better paying jobs.

To increase the minimum wage will serve to eliminate many starting jobs because of added business costs and the increased use of automation. The last thing we need now is fewer jobs.

As a conservative I have worked at minimum wage when it was $3.25 per hour during summer when I was in school. I was happy to be able to make money back then, never expecting to do manual labor day-in and day-out hauling construction lumber on the job site. It was a start and I was proud to show that job when I put together my first resume.  So when people call me heartless regarding the minimum wage..I’ve lived it and moved on.

It seems to be those clamoring for a minimum labor rate providing enough money on which to live comfortably, need to be hit in the head with a 4 X 4. Students going to school, many retired individuals, and those just out of prison need work to supplement retirement, or as a foundation before moving upward. For those who dropped out of school, decided drugs and substance abuse was better than learning a skill or moving on to higher education and those who haven’t cut the umbilical cord and are mooching off their parents, why should the income of those hard working mainstream Americans be redistributed as a reward for bad choices made on life’s highway?

It is one thing for those feel-good liberals to talk about an increased minimum wage, but is $10.00/hour any more compassionate than $7.25? So why not shoot for $20/hour and maybe that would satisfy them?  But what would that do for the rest of us who paid our taxes and live off what we earn?

Let’s take the fast food franchise business…you know… Burger King, Dominos, and others, to see how that would affect the cost of the food they serve.  Restaurants traditionally experience a labor expense of between 25-38%, meaning for every dollar in sales, 25-38% of the revenue generated goes toward paying the labor cost to deliver the food.  Let’s use 38% and cover the cost of payroll taxes as well and address the cheapie hamburger selling for $1.50 with the minimum wage at $7.25.

Now let’s increase the minimum wage to $10/hr, as has been suggested by many on the left. That’s about a 35% increase in the cost of labor (not including the 2013 tax Armageddon small business will be experiencing beginning in January 2013 which increases the employers tax contribution and exposure to Obamabcare). That means the cost of the $1.50 hamburger would have to be raised to $2.02 to offset the increased labor cost. The Double Whopper Meal at $5.49 would now cost $7.40.  A Dominos 3-topping takeout pizza would rise from $7.99 to $10.78.

How many fewer hamburgers and pizzas would be sold since most of the rest of use hard working tax payers are stuck in the stagnant economy which has already seen our annual incomes drop by $4500 annually Do you suppose the American public would purchase the same numbers of burgers and pizza or would they buy less? Would the franchise food place need as many workers with fewer sales or less workers?

This example can be applied to every small business, but very few Americans understand how a business operates. Most go to work, come home, watch reality television, and pick-up their paycheck at the end of the week. Little do they know or understand the cost of doing business and the effect government regulation already has on small business which is anything but helping American get back to work. Most have no idea what “regulations” mean.

To mention a few:

  • EIN Federal Employee Identification Number. Everyone who owns a business must have an EIN.
  • Business license
  • Business occupation permit
  • Sales tax permit
  • Many cities and counties even require p[ermits for garage and yard
  • Permits for fundraising events, parades, and celebrations
  • Worker’s Compensation Insurance
  • Health Operational Permit – This is necessary for the selling of edible goods. Each state and county have their own set of rules and amount of fees charged. These permit entitles you to periodical inspections by the city’s health inspector to see if you are operating a safe and clean retail food facility. Written reports will be given for a list of violations and tasks to be completed before the next inspection.
  • Food Handler’s Permit– It is required that each food facility shall have an owner or employee who has successfully passed an approved and accredited food safety certification examination even that the certified owner or employee need not be present at the food facility during all hours of operation.
  • Sign Permit– Before you put up any signs for your restaurant.  This may come with all kinds of restrictions
  • Alcoholic beverage license (ABC License) — If you plan on selling alcoholic
  • A music license band, DJ playing CDs, or Karaoke
  • Legal building permits for your new construction or tenant improvement, including The Environmental Health Department
  • The Planning and Zoning Division
  • The Building Department
  • The Fire Department
  • The Sanitary and Public Sewage Department
  • Environmental impact study in some cases
  • Added to all this is the cost of insurance for the business including liability, flood, storm, accident, and on and on.

Right now, there are roughly 170,000 federal business regulations currently on the books, many going beyond local regulations. Written in fine print, single-spaced and double-columned, they fill about 150,000 pages of text. In 2008 alone, regulations cost the U.S. economy $1.75 trillion, according to a report from the Small Business Administration. That’s equal to a whopping 14 percent of the nation’s gross domestic product. Add that to the nation’s tax burden, and it’s easy to see how the federal government is stifling businesses, undermining employment growth and handicapping America’s global competitiveness.

In 2010 alone, despite the weak economy, the Obama Administration issued 3,752 new rules – and 224 of them cost more than $100 million.

I say, with 20 million out of work, this Thanksgiving these workers should be thankful they have a job, or go somewhere else to work!

Surely, not all of Washington’s regulations can be said to improve workplace safety or public health. Unaccountable bureaucrats continue to establish new hurdles for business owners  to jump through without regard for the costs imposed. Managers get buried under paperwork that often provides little to no value to their workforces or the public, with the average small businesses suffering the most. The average firm with fewer than 20 employees faces regulatory costs 42 percent higher than businesses with up to 500 employees. The average regulatory compliance costs for each employee of a small business now exceed $10,000 per year, according to the SBA report.

The American electorate voted for four more years of PAIN, because most do not understand the plight of those doing the hiring…small business. When they mentioned the burden of government with its regulation and taxes, the class warfare gang said in the loudest of voices that could be trumpeted through the administration …YEAH!!! Punish those suckers! Little did the populace realize they are killing what is needed to save America and its jobs.

So now let’s go after the rest of the businesses which provide jobs…Walmart, K-Mart, Target, Best Buy, and others on this Black Friday shopping season. How many of the workers in these businesses are being FORCED TO WORK THERE? If they don’t like working at these places, by all means go find work elsewhere. So I say…Let employee-agitators demand more pay when 20 million are out of work. Let them demand union participation after having just driven Hostess Cupcakes out of business (18,000 jobs lost), and let’s invest more money we borrow from China on Government boondoggles like Solyndra.

Enough is enough. I say let these companies fire all those who walkout on Black Friday and open the door to the millions who would be thankful for an opportunity to work. Yes, at $7.25 an hour it’s not much, but with a little real government help which could include the earned income credit, the child tax credit and, if needed, a little public assistance with food stamps, there will be a line waiting for those valuable jobs!


  1. I do what other writers do. I talk about what’s on my mind. If everyone wrote about the same thing, life would be boring and we can’t have that at VT. It’s an open platform and you are free to pick and choose what you you read. There’s a lot I don’t agree with from the other writers, but seldom reply. By the way…you’ll note I always footnote my facts and not just pull them out of thin air.

  2. The banking and corporate elites along with their media and political tools have managed to turn gullible people against their fellow working man. Its an age old tactic by elites but their media/propaganda arm is more advanced than ever so you see the sheeple attack the weakest and poorest among us with particular vigor.

    You see certain people spew what they hear on tv/radio like its their own thoughts. Right after the election the narrative among the gullible group that has turned on their fellow man instead of on who they should have was as follows-Obama won because of “free stuff”. People wanted “handouts”. Wrong. He was seen as less likely to attack the social safety net, true. He was also seen as more “relatable”. Understandable given the nature of Romneys privileged life and cold, robot-like nature. Finally Obama was seen as less of a warmonger than empty suit Romney and those who surrounded him(team Bush/Zakheim/Chertoff). Nevermind that Obama is the drone king and just got done bending over for Israel while they committed atrocities in Gaza. Obama was the lesser of 2 evils. It had nothing to do with this subtle racist and classist narrative that Obama won on the strength of “handouts”. That divisive narrative may make certain people feel better but its not true. Obamas talking about how Social Security and Medicare are “on the table”, which is DC speak for its going to be cut or worse. Plus plenty of morons of all colors, including many whites, voted for Obama just like many morons of all stripes voted for Romney. MIllions of people voted against their own self interests when they voted for Rombama.

  3. “If they don’t like working at these places, by all means go find work elsewhere.”

    Hmmm…, so why do the bankers deliberately keep unemployment higher than it needs to be, while destroying the social safety net – perhaps so workers can be kept as virtual slaves by multinational corporations owned by the banks (who in turn are owned by families whose wealth makes Buffet, Gates, and Slim look decidedly middle class)?

  4. Of course, the right-wing “logic” of keeping wages down harms the small business retailer, as the low-paid workers have little money to spend, and what they do have goes to Sprawl-Mart. Even noted union-buster Henry Ford knew he had to pay his workers enough to buy his cars for Ford Motor Company to succeed – something that has been (deliberately in many cases) forgotten by the current super rich in their orgy of greed.

  5. Let us just ignore the successes of the Northern European economies with much higher minimum wages, much greater mandatory paid vacations, and a much more comprehensive social safety net than the US – or are they just better than USians and if so why? (*Not* my theory, but many on the right bring up the racist notion of ethnic homogeneity for the Northern European success).

  6. He also conveniently forgets that it wasn’t too long ago that the system worked very well indeed.

    That’s when much of our existing public infrastructure was created.

    A family with one breadwinner could enjoy a comfortable and fullfilling life.

    We became complacent. We forgot of the battle our forefathers had fought for a little justice and dignity in this world and the elitist scum once again took advantage of our geniality and generosity of spirit.

    Now look at where we are…

  7. Charlotte NC Bill,
    You are right on. It seems that Ed forgets about the reality here in the working class and all the resources and people and money spent on geo-political chess and foreign aggressive occupation and construction for less then nobel reasons. Thanks for enlightening him a bit. I know he likes to have new information. I am not sure he knows what to do with it since he is in a concrete attitude much of the time.

  8. “The populace” in these countries ” struggles daily w/o a safety net on perpetually low wages…sounds like most of the US populace there Ed…Most construction workers in Charlotte make $15-$17 hr and they can’t make ends meet w/o o/t….which they’re more than willing to work….More public works jobs would help…but we’re too busy building highways across Afghanistan and paying for fertilizer and irrigation so the CIA can run processed heroin to Camp Bondsteel so our KLA allies can mule the stuff across Europe for us…Or we were too busy paying Bechtel and Halliburton/KBR to “rebuild” Iraq….Too busy paying Blackwater snipers $300 day..what hypocrisy…these slurpers at the public trough are a big part of the Republican coalition…But we’re worried about the exorbitant min wage…

  9. “undercurrent of anti-semitism”…Clueless as usual…Can’t imagine why the gentile victims of Judeo-bolshevism in E. and C. europe would be anti-“Jewish” “(khazar)…Might have something to do with the fact that anti-gentile khazars ran the NKVD ( secret police), ran the gulags, killed the Czar and his family, turned Orthodox churches into dance halls and slaughter houses…chopped the noses and ears off priests before throwing them into the freezing waters…ripped Orthodox nuns out of their convent to pick lice off of blankets during the White Sea Canal project..( where about 1/4 million gentiles were worked to death by the Khazar guards ) ..No, can’t imagine why any of them would hold a grudge!! Actually, they’ve been overly charitable and restrained…

  10. Social engineering has never worked. Having lived in Eastern Europe we saw many examples of not only social engineering but government central planning. Talk about FUBAR! All it has done is imprisoned folks to mediocrity with a big undercurrent of antisemitism. Wages are fairly equal (accept for the ruling classes who live well beyond the norm), and the populace struggles daily without a safety net on perpetually low incomes. It is nearly impossible to rise above the norm unless one flees to countries like the US. Once here (like my wife and son) they can’t believe Americans want to adopt the same types of economies they just fled. Redundancy of worn out ideas never seems to make them any better because they are doomed to failure at the start. In the US at least for the time being, people have the option to move from job to job to better their chances in life. By the time the unions finish with us, that option too will be taken from us.

  11. Well, liberals are political scientists, so they should be able to calculate the perfect minimum wage (for every country if the numbers are different) and it should be a number which can be proven, maybe 46.7 percent of the median income (even if statisticians know three kinds of “median”).

    Great article, it could be part 5 of Thomas Sowell’s “A Political Glossary” four part series.

  12. Ed it sounds like you are angry or just like to stir things up. When I got back from Vietnam and out of the Army I bought a car with my savings alotment and got a job in a machine shop working on lathes for a little above minimum wages with no experience. After a few years experience I realized I was being treated badly with no benefits and if I wanted to keep my job I had to work 70 hours a week. And I was still making barely over the minimum wage with 2 kids and a wife. Well I had enough time in to change factories and join the United Steel Workers Union. It was like day and night. Organiztion, clear rules, much safer working conditions compared to the non-union shops, a fair wage with benefits and a ladder up with more experience over time on more complicated machines. Then downsizing, outsourcing, layoffs, and I ended up in K-Mart with much less per hour, no benefits and low morale. Anyway, my struggle landed me in college with a couple degrees in my 30s and a job in the Federal Government, in a Union with a fair wage and benefits and some sense of security and retirement to look forward to. While my wages slowly went up over time, the top few percent of the most wealthy’s wages or legalized robbery and gambling money went up astronomically. This curve started about the time Reagan came into power. Coincidence? Probably not. Whats a guy to do? I feel fortunate but it took a long time after the War for me to get here. Most working class folks struggle but are partially responsible for their situation. The marketing of stuff that we are enticed to buy is ridiculous. Growing up we had no fast food, no going out to eat, had our own gardens, had extended family support, and discipline around saving and spending, didnt respond to marketing of products that were expensive and that we didnt need. Well all this has changed and humanity is not always better for it. People want that new widget, tablet, game, car, dress, shirt, sofa, house, boat, fast food, better kitchen, new fireplace, etc. So we are enticed to buy things we do not need and probably cannot afford. So we enable the crooked market to enslave us into this insane consumer culture with very little sense of community or soul. I don’t know the answer. It is so much more complicated then what the minimum wage is. It takes all of us examining our habitual patterns of waste and lack of discipline and lack of compassion or understanding of the other class or race or people we live amongst. Co-operation, community and intelligent compassion are whats needed. Only then can this minimum wage issue or whatever you are talking about evolve.

Comments are closed.